5

We always ask that when you post an question, you only ask about one particular plant type in that post. Be specific!

  • This allows answers to be much less vague - especially if it's a hard question, with multiple 'possible' answers. To allow for the voting up of a correct answer, and avoiding long discussions.
  • It makes searching for a specific plant much easier (as a site user, or as someone searching online).
  • It keeps the answers short and simple. Again, it should be easy as possible for others searching for the identification of that particular plant to find the answer easily.

If you post a picture including several species or varieties, please specify which one in particular you are asking about.

If you are interested in the identification of the species of a group of plants, such as (for example) a colorful zinnia mix, where they are all obviously the same species, but not variety, you can ask, as a whole, what plants they are. If you are interested in the particular varieties, you would be required to post pictures of each, in their own questions, to avoid being too broad

You can post identification questions asking for a health diagnosis.

In that case, it can be appropriate to ask for the identification of 2 species (the affected plant, and the pest/disease). Proper tagging would include , , and , , , , etc. The more specific you can be, the better.

In the case of parasitic plants, that is probably the only instance when asking for the ID of more than one plant species per post is called for.

Posts asking for the identification of multiple plants should be closed as 'Too Broad'.

For new users, it would be good to leave them a nice comment, to let them know of this rule (you can link this post, or to the identification tag wiki, as a reference). If they don't take any action in altering their post, it can be closed.

And lastly, just as for any post that is considered off topic, please do not answer it (not even in the comments), as that does a poor job of educating the user, and increases the likelihood of them posting in a similar manner again.

3

In general I agree, but there are exceptions:

  • wild plants: sometime an image with a nearby flower (and thus identify the flower in one question) is much easier (or just possible).

  • some plants require a host. For orchids and epiphytes: they are just one identification.

  • plant and disease (or fungi or insects): identification of both plant and disease (etc.) is better in one answer, with a single explanation.

From the last item(s) come the most obvious examples (and possibly not covered by the original question), but it shows the rule. In my opinion the soft line should be inside the "wild plants": not OK if they are different plants found in different areas on the same trip; OK for plants that are usually found together.

  • Thanks for the feedback, Giacomo! Item 1: I think that that case will benefit from one plant per post rule just like other situations. People should make sure to take good pictures of the plants they are interested in. Item 2: In this case, I think it's only necessary to include host plant and epiphyte if the plant you are interested in looks different on different hosts. Otherwise, again, it's better to separate them. Item 3: Yes, in the case that a pest or disease is damaging an unknown plant, it is appropriate for them both to be included in one post. – J. Musser Sep 21 '17 at 23:35
  • See the newest edit to the post. – J. Musser Sep 21 '17 at 23:50

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .