it's almost spring time now! If you've been watching our traffic stats, you would've noticed a near doubling of traffic in just about two months. Indeed, more and more folks are getting to know about us from Google searches (yes, more than 90% of our traffic comes from search, which is great!) as seen from the charts for traffic (left) and Q&A (right) since last Fall.

enter image description here enter image description here

First impressions:

With all these new eyes and potential new users, it is important to make a good impression and make newbies feel welcome here. To that effect, here are some things you could do (if you have not been doing already):

  • Welcome new users to the site; fix up spelling/grammar mistakes in their posts and provide suggestions to improve their post. Install the Autoreview pro-forma comments userscript, which makes leaving such comments a piece of cake.
  • Vote regularly and vote often. If you see a well written question that's useful (doesn't matter if it is immediately relevant to you or not), upvote it. Upvote good answers. Also remind new users that they should upvote good content. It is equally important to downvote bad/poor content. Remember that votes can always be changed if the post is edited, so if you downvote and leave a comment to that effect, it actually helps the user improve (upon which you can change your vote).
  • Vote to close (requires 500 rep in beta) if a question is a duplicate/off-topic/not-a-real-question/other. It takes 5 community votes to close and 5 to reopen. We haven't seen as many off-topic questions in the past few months as we have in the first month or two of beta, but things will certainly change with the increased exposure. Users with <500 rep can cast close flags.

    Closing a post is something that a lot of users (especially those new to SE) take personally. It is important to remember that closing is not permanent. Let them know in a comment, as to why their post was closed (or is attracting close votes) and how they can fix it to get it reopened. Let them know about the means they have at their disposal to protest a closure — flag/meta/chat.

  • If you see a new user's (good) question not getting enough attention, consider placing a modest bounty on their question. Some of us have been doing it regularly, but it's always nice to get community participation. Let them know why you're doing it and what a bounty does, so that they understand and hopefully, they'll remember and return the favor to the community in the future when they're in a position to spare some rep. Never let a new user go for days without getting an answer.

The road to graduation:

Now you all know that we've been in beta for about 9 months now, and we should really be aiming at graduating sometime this year. While the exact details of what it takes to graduate are fuzzy, here are some areas we could improve that I, in my experience with Stack Exchange, feel will help us greatly.

  • Voting:
    Very few of our users actually vote (you can search for your name to see how many you've cast). Only 10 have the Civic Duty badge and about 20 each for the Suffrage and Vox-populi badges — this is from 900+ users and 160+ who are considered "Avid users". This number certainly needs to improve.
  • Editing:
    It is OK to edit other people's posts, as long as the meaning and intent is not changed. Please fix links/add references/correct mistakes/improve formatting, etc. in posts as you come across them. Editing stats are even worse than voting and only 5 have the Strunk & White badge and a single Copy Editor badge.
  • Tag wikis:
    Often neglected by most, tag wikis serve to convey what the tag is used for. It is not, however, a substitute for Wikipedia. So please edit the common tags to provide tips on using that tag, some FAQs in the tag, what not to use that tag for, etc. There's even a cool Research Assistant badge for it, that only 1 user has as of now. I personally think that and are good examples of tag wikis done right.
  • Meta activity:
    A larger and more vocal community is good in ensuring that different view points are heard in . This means stepping up and posting an answer even if it is contrary to the popular opinion. If you agree/disagree with existing answers, vote accordingly! If you see something tagged as , do not hesitate to provide an answer if you know it.
  • Chatroom activity:
    A dead chatroom is not a very pleasant place to hang out. Try to drop in every day or every other day. Share your garden with others (some of them do that regularly). Discuss your issues more loosely with your fellow users instead of in a rigid Q&A format. Having an active chatroom also gives new users (those with 20 rep) a place to hang out and maybe learn the ways here or bounce their question for a quick sanity check on whether it'll fly on the main site, etc.
  • Community blog:
    While there was initial interest in a community blog, we need more volunteers and a decent plan for potential topics in order to actually move forward. Share your ideas — even if you can't write, just propose potential topics. Perhaps someone else can write them.

How can you help?:

You can help us improve in all these areas by participating in a community driven spring cleanup and a focused effort to polish the site. There's something that everyone can do, no matter what their rep or gardening experience.

  • Make use of the /review page and improve it where ever you can.
  • Go through old posts, from the early days and see if they need retagging or other improvements (be a little careful here as to not introduce any new wild and over-specific tags).
  • If you come across a post that you haven't seen before, pause to read it and upvote it if it's worthy. Perhaps you can try browsing through the list of unanswered questions and see if something can be answered.
  • Got ideas for our final design? Suggest them as an answer to this meta question.
  • Let your friends know and share a link to this site on your twitter/blog/facebook/what-have-you to improve our visibility.

In the past, people have tended to worry about the statistics on Area51. Do not focus on the statistics, but instead on our content. I believe we have a great Q&A resource on gardening and landscaping and that beats any crummy stats. What we need to build now is a community spirit and collectively take part in the site's janitorial work.

  • 2
    Boy, I haven't been doing much but voting and editing, and posting occasionally. Thanks for this post. I think I do pretty well with voting, but have a lot to polish up on. I vote because no one else but you was doing it much.
    – J. Musser
    Commented Mar 21, 2012 at 1:55
  • Where can I find the traffic data?
    – Om Patange
    Commented Mar 24, 2012 at 22:28
  • Also, what are the benefits of graduation other than a new look? Is there a good place to read about that?
    – Om Patange
    Commented Mar 24, 2012 at 22:29
  • 1
    I think the benefit is that the site won't be removed. Commented Mar 27, 2012 at 8:48

1 Answer 1


One thing we could do that is a service to every gardener is a community article listing all the ideas that are not true. For example:

  • using bone meal for bulbs
  • using high nitrogen fertilizer for your lawn\
  • planting by the phase of the moon
  • putting black tar over a tree wound

this and many other ideas are found all over the web and do a dis-service to the public by perpetuating ideas which have no basis from research.

And @yoda has it right when they say that a dead chatroom is a deterrent. Having followed other online activities which can attract people from around the world it is unreasonable to expect someone hanging around 24/7. And chat rooms also have the issue that having something worth saying is better than typing for nothing for something to do.

Could we ask members to host a five minute session at good times on a topic? This might help with what to talk about and if no one is visiting then....cut and paste is your friend!

  • Our friends at Skeptics have the lunar planting one covered pretty well. I agree with your suggestion — the best way to root out wrong information is to post the right information and make it popular by linking to it from places and other questions on this site that it's applicable. To that effect, you can also ask & answer your own question or each one can take one to ask/answer. To start, I'll ask a question on the tar one later tonight, so that you can answer it. Commented Mar 18, 2012 at 23:15
  • 1
    Here you go gardening.stackexchange.com/q/3666/109 :) Commented Mar 20, 2012 at 0:20
  • Also re: your edit, yes, I do plan on having a system wide message for a chat session this weekend so that we can brainstorm on stuff like this to get it started. Please watch out for a meta post/system banner :) Commented Mar 20, 2012 at 0:22
  • I'll try to drop by if I can but I already know it is going to be a busy weekend...
    – winwaed
    Commented Mar 23, 2012 at 12:32
  • 1
    Ever the problem, if you are a gardener you are outside gardening and not inside at a computer!
    – kevinskio Mod
    Commented Mar 23, 2012 at 13:38

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .